
Last night I taught my church’s FAITH curriculum to a really sharp group. We were exploring humanity’s relationship with God before the Fall and a lot of the usual phrases were used: Intimate, comfortable, and personal. One perceptive individual pointed out from the beginning God’s relationship with Adam and Eve included “death threats.”
The matter of fact manner in which she said this caught me off guard, but she’s not wrong. Genesis Two is the story a paradise, created by a loving and perfect Divine Being, who tells the first couple to enjoy creation. But one caveat: Eat from the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil and you’ll die.
When I step back and separate myself from being overly familiar with Scripture, God’s pronouncement does sound like a death threat. If I was at a bank and I heard, “Touch that alarm buzzer or I’ll shoot” I’d count that as a death threat immediately after I finished soiling myself.
Perhaps the words placed a seed of doubt in Eve’s heart that made her vulnerable to Satan’s treachery. We know that Adam and Eve made for the bushes the next time God showed up for his daily visit. Adam said it was because they were “naked and ashamed.” Perhaps Adam was afraid that these new emotions were the precursor to an immediate execution so he hid himself and Eve.
We kicked this idea around before deciding that what what play wasn’t anything like a capricious death threat, but a parental warning. When my children were young I gave them stern warnings about riding their bikes in the road: ” A car will hit you and you could die.”
What there a threat of death in my statement? Absolutely.
Would a passerby report me to the authorities for abusive language? Absolutely not.
God knew that through their disobedience Adam and Eve would be passing through a door, but unlike the wardrobe in the Chronicles of Narnia, they would not be passing into a magical world, but leaving one. Also, unlike the Chronicles of Narnia, movement through this door was “one way.” There could be no return to Eden.
So the most loving thing God could do was to warn them of impending death.