At the end of Moses’ life, he stood in front of his nation and reminded his people about the terms of their covenant with God. Moses reminded his people that God didn’t choose them because of a stellar track record of getting it right. They never were able to mind their spiritual P’s and Q’s. Instead, God loved them… because he loved them (Deuteronomy 7:4-7). He forecasted that just as they had not kept the terms of the covenant in the past, they would not be able to do so in the future either. Even with this glum assessment of Israel’s fidelity to God, Moses lays out the content of what we now call the book of Deuteronomy. The very act of his preaching the covenant in the face of that truth served as a reminder that God’s commitment and love for his people wasn’t connected to their moral condition.
“He loves you… because he has loved you.”
In our day, another man, no less a patriarch, stands at the last chapters of his life and offers his final thoughts to a band of ragamuffin believers. In the 1970′s, Brennan Manning began to capture our imagination by describing a God “who loved us, not for how we should be, but because of how we are, because nobody is as they should be.” Brennan is a former priest and a recovering alcoholic who had the audacity to believe that none of his failures repulsed God to point of breaking intimacy with him.
Now, after years of silence Brennan offers us a memoir revealing intimate details of his ragamuffin life. Brennan’s mind is weakened by the effects of a life-time of alcoholism.”Wet brain”, he calls it. Even so, Brennan looks back, with the help of his co-writer, John Blase, and recounts episodes from his story. Brennan offers the details of growing up with his cold and critical mother (If she’d been born in a later era, she might have been described as having an attachment disorder), and his time in the army and seminary. The reader is introduced to his great romance with Rosalyn, his decision to leave the priesthood for her, and her patience in waiting for him. He recounts how his addiction tore at the fabric of marital love until it frayed beyond repair. Brennan’s transparency tells a story that runs counter to those our Evangelical subculture seems to adore: Tales of moral misfits who encounter Jesus and quick and permanent freedom from their vices. Brennan’s “Abba experience” and vibrant faith was powerless to loosen the grip of addiction over his body. Brennan’s Jesus is not a spiritual commodity that improved his life, but a companion that loved him in throughout his life, such as it was.
Philip Yancey makes a sole complaint about Brennan’s memoir in his forward: He tells no stories that cast him in a good light. He is content to let his audience see his brokenness. This creates another similarity between he and Moses. Moses incriminates himself when he describes the faithlessness of the people he has been called to lead. His best efforts weren’t enough to change the character of the people God charged him with leading. His sense of inadequacy was enough to drive him to strike the rock in frustration. And yet, Moses ended his life with convinced of his core message, that God “loved them because he loved them.” In the same way, Brennan’s life-struggle left him with the hard earned knowledge that the worst of our failures cannot separate us from the love of God.
“God loves us as we are, not as we should be.”
…
I’d be remiss if I didn’t offer a note about Brennan’s co-writer. John Blase is a gifted author with a rich and distinct voice of his own. His blog, The Beautiful Due, has become required reading for the maintenance of my soul. He writes poems about being ambushed by grace a midst the weariness of life. I closed All is Grace impressed his humility. He did what a good co-writer should do in this situation and subjugated his voice and style to another. John served Brennan’s message and style like a veteran waitstaff at a fine restaurant. The diners leave remembering the fine meal but forget their waiter. Do yourself a favor and visit his blog. John is a master chef in his own right. You won’t be disappointed.